November 19, 2026
Last November, the family behind Scott's Farm Store posted on Facebook that the 2025 Christmas season would be their last at 356 Middlesex Turnpike. Patch reported that the land had been sold, and that the store had been selling trees and handmade wreaths since the 1980s. This year a different business is selling Christmas trees at that address. Meanwhile the ingredients for the holiday table have picked up a new Main Street stop, inside a building on the National Register of Historic Places that most people in town knew as a restaurant.
So this December you buy from the same corners as last year, but you'll find different counters on them. Here is the town as it looks the week before Thanksgiving, organized as a route, from the turnpike down to the Post Road and over the town line for anyone who wants to cut their own tree.
The Old Saybrook Garden Center was announced in February 2026 for the former Scott's site. It is not connected to the Scott's family. By June, the E List's guide to local farm stands listed it as open for plants and tropicals, with produce on the way.
The center's website lists seasonal Christmas trees and handmade wreaths. The tree page describes trees from 5 to 10 feet tall, sold in store only, and says delivery is available. If you used to pick up your wreath at Scott's after school drop-off, you'll pull into the same driveway, now with a new business behind the counter.
The other in-town option is Maynard Greenhouses at 89 Ingham Hill Road. Its listing names Christmas trees, wreaths and evergreen arrangements as part of its holiday selection.
The bigger change for the holiday table sits near the Main Street corner of Pennywise Lane.
Anna Louise James ran her drugstore in this building and lived here too. According to the National Register nomination, she was Connecticut's first African American woman pharmacist. The same nomination dates the building to about 1820 and places it within the Old Saybrook South Green Historic District. More recently the building held a French restaurant, Cocotte, and then a Moroccan one, Tissa's Le Souk Du Maroc. Both worked out of a tiny kitchen with very little seating.
Chef Colt Taylor moved The Essex to Old Saybrook's Main Street in December 2021. In May, CT Examiner reported that he had found a local partner to buy the old pharmacy. Town Hall had told him another offer would have made it a private residence. He kept the name. His crew pulled about 50 years' worth of James Pharmacy signs out of the basement and planned to restore them and hang them in the shop. The old demilune pocket windows work again.
The shop calls itself a "modernized old school butcher shop and culinary general store." It sells fine meats cut to order, Wagyu and prime beef, daily rotisserie chicken, chef sandwiches, prepared foods, Japanese knives and pantry staples. In the CT Examiner piece, Taylor said he was going for a short list of very good choices over grocery-store variety, with cuts you don't see everywhere, like chuck flap tail and tri-tip. He also named American Wagyu, dry-aged beef, house-made sausage, Jurgielewicz & Son duck from Long Island, Snake River Farm beef and Hudson Valley chicken. Before settling on that plan, he met with the neighbors. The shop is take-out only and sells no alcohol, which suits a building on a residential block.
The E List gave the shop's address as 323 Main Street and wrote about it as an operating shop in July. Posted hours are Tuesday through Saturday 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., closed Monday. The ice cream window is closed for the season. For this first Thanksgiving, the shop took orders for whole turkeys, house-made sides and 10-inch pies. Ordering closed November 12, and CT Bites lists pickup for November 24 and 25. That cutoff came two weeks before the holiday. If you're planning a Christmas roast, it makes sense to ask at the counter in early December.
Walt's Market at 178 Main Street was already the town's butcher long before the pharmacy reopened. In 2014, the E List wrote that it had recently celebrated 50 years in business. For Thanksgiving 2026 it is taking phone orders for Waybest turkeys from 10 to 22 pounds, plus holiday sides. In a November 15, 2026 holiday feature, Connecticut Magazine mentioned Walt's steaks and kielbasa, along with Fenwick ice cream made in house.
Dagmar's Desserts handles the sweet side of the table. The E List's 2026 holiday guide lists apple strudel, Stollen, tarts and cakes. Its Thanksgiving menu took orders by phone or in person through Wednesday, November 18, paid in advance. If Stollen is on your Christmas morning list, that same early, prepaid pattern is a good assumption. Dagmar's is also on the list of businesses in the Chamber's Saybrook Starlight Festival on December 5.
The same stretch of Main Street covers the gifts. Connecticut Magazine's holiday piece names Harbor Books at 146 Main Street, which sells new and used books, including nautical, Katharine Hepburn and local-history titles. It also names Saybrook Home at 2 Main Street for furniture, rugs and clothing, and Maximus Home at 143 Main Street, a 4,500-square-foot multi-vendor shop for vintage, antiques and décor. Driftwood at 264 Main Street and Cottage Flair at 168 Main Street round out its list. Pearls & Plaid at 117 Main Street has posted a 2026 holiday gift guide on its site. The same article reports that merchants from Boston Post Road through Main Street are running promotions for Small Business Saturday, November 28.
Two Chamber events also bring you to these doors. Ladies Night on Friday, December 4, has discounts at participating Main Street businesses, a prize drawing and gift wrapping. The Elf Hunt runs December 5 through 12. A passport costs $5, and the first 150 passports sold qualify for a goodie bag once their holders visit at least eight locations. Every elf you find is one more entry in the prize drawing. Passports are due back December 12, and winners are announced Monday, December 14. We wrote about the Starlight Festival and the Torchlight Parade in Old Saybrook's Main Street Has Two Christmases, Not One.
The Christmas Eve fish and the cheese board come from the Post Road. Atlantic Seafood Market at 1400 Boston Post Road has been in town since 1978. It sells fresh fish and shellfish, seafood salads, and chef-prepared meals and soups every day, and its site mentions pickup for holiday orders.
Fromage Fine Foods & Coffees at 873 Boston Post Road has its 2026 holiday brochure out. It lists cheeses, artisanal breads, olives, specialty meats, pâté, caviar, teas, coffees and gift baskets. If you're shipping a basket to family out of state, note that the brochure suggests ordering early and says UPS will not guarantee shipments after December 10.
If your household goes out to cut a tree, Killingworth and Clinton are both an easy drive. Winterberry Farm at 104 Parker Hill Road Extension in Killingworth opens for 2026 the day after Thanksgiving, Friday, November 27. Hours are 9 to 4:30 on weekends and 1 to 4:30 on weekdays through December 18. Trees are $75 this season, tax included. The farm also sells wreaths, kissing balls and greens, and weekend hot-chocolate donations go to the Paul Dostie KARE Foundation.
In Clinton, Dolan Christmas Tree Farm at 69 Kelseytown Road is listed with the Connecticut Christmas Tree Growers Association at $60 a tree, with wreaths and Thursday and Friday hours from noon to 4. The farm asks visitors to call ahead to meet someone there for cutting or pickup, so call before you load up the car. Christmas Acres Tree Farm is next door at 67 Kelseytown Road, a second choose-and-cut farm on the same road.
The early order windows are what get people. This fall, the James Pharmacy closed Thanksgiving orders on November 12 and Dagmar's on November 18, and Fromage's shipping caveat falls on December 10. Put together, that means the first week of December is a good time to place orders: stop at the counter on Main Street, call the bakery, and get the out-of-state basket going. The Elf Hunt opens on Saturday, December 5, the same day as the Starlight stroll, so the first round of errands can share that trip.
A new tree lot at 356 Middlesex Turnpike and a butcher in the James Pharmacy are the kind of changes I pass along to clients settling into Old Saybrook, along with which stretch of Main Street is within walking distance of their new front door. If you'd like to talk about life in town this season, or what it's like to live within reach of Main Street, Teri Lewis would be glad to hear from you. Request a Concierge Consultation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Teri is extremely personable and will work tirelessly for your needs. Her attention to detail and her honest and personable approach is what she longs for each in every transaction. She will not only find you a home, but will also help you find the right fit for your family and also give you a concierge approach when transitioning into the area she so loves.