November 5, 2026
From April 23 to July 25, 2025, engineers at the Old Saybrook High School site ran clean water into the ground. They wanted to see whether the soil there could take treated wastewater from homes near the shore. The test ended, the field hockey field went onto a restoration plan, and by May 2026 the Water Pollution Control Authority was meeting with state regulators about an environmental review and what its minutes call "a resolution referendum."
If you are comparing beach neighborhoods south of Route 1, that test site matters more than most listing details. Old Saybrook has no public sewers. The town's plan for its last unfinished shoreline areas would change that for some streets and not others. Two cottages with similar views and similar prices can have very different wastewater histories and very different costs ahead.
Since 2009, Old Saybrook has run a Decentralized Wastewater Management District. Fuss & O'Neill, the town's engineering firm, calls it the first project of its kind in Connecticut. The district covers about 1,900 properties in 15 focus areas in the southern part of town. The firm describes that ground as having "shallow depth to groundwater, poor soils, and high-density development," like many beach communities along Long Island Sound.
Phases I and II dealt with most of the district through on-site septic upgrades. In its fiscal year 2025 report, the WPCA said those two phases had upgraded 59% of the properties in the program. The same report says the town is working to satisfy DEEP and a "court-stipulated judgement" at the lowest possible cost to district residents.
Those earlier phases also came with bills. Phase I and II benefit assessments for hard construction and construction management went out in October 2025, with payments due in November 2025 and May 2026. The Tax Collector processes them. WPCA minutes from November 10, 2025 record that the November deadline moved to December 6 after the mailing was delayed.
Phase III covers what Phases I and II could not fix lot by lot. The FY2025 report names the five remaining beach areas: Plum Bank, Great Hammock Beach, Saybrook Manor, Indiantown and Chalker Beach. It also lists eight remaining houses in Cornfield Point and the remaining "W" lots in the first ten focus areas.
The WPCA's October 2026 request for qualifications describes the endorsed solution, Alternative 1, this way:
"public sewers composed of low pressure collector sewers and a packaged membrane bioreactor (MBR) wastewater renovation recovery facility (WRRF) for the remaining 645 properties within the remaining 5 Focus Areas"
Under that plan, treated water would be dispersed underground at the high school site. Another 66 properties scattered along the shoreline in the other ten focus areas would get on-site septic improvements.
Here is how the district sorts out for someone looking at a specific street:
| Focus areas | Where they stand in Phase III |
|---|---|
| Plum Bank, Great Hammock Beach, Saybrook Manor, Indiantown, Chalker Beach | Low-pressure public sewers for 645 properties under endorsed Alternative 1 |
| Cornfield Park, Cornfield Point, Meadowood, Maple Avenue North, Fenwood, Ingham Hill, Oyster River East, Saybrook Acres, Saybrook Point, Thompson | Mostly handled in Phases I and II; 66 properties spread across these areas slated for on-site septic improvements |
| Townwide on-site septic program | Pump-out, inspection and maintenance under the town's on-site ordinance |
Within the second group, the street name doesn't settle much. A cottage in Cornfield Point could be one of the houses already upgraded, or one of the eight the town still lists as remaining.
The high school site is in the plan because of the soil in the beach areas. Fuss & O'Neill says the 575 homes it counts as sitting next to surface water need "an off-site solution." That is engineering language for lots that cannot treat their own wastewater well enough on land that small and that wet. The firm says the planned community system "will be the largest in Connecticut." It calls the system cost-effective compared with a conventional treatment plant discharging to the Connecticut River.
That river option is still being studied as Alternative 2. It uses the same low-pressure sewers, adds a pump station and force main, and puts the treatment plant next to the Connecticut River, with an outfall near Rome Tree Drive. In a May 2026 engineering presentation, Alternative 2 also lists Route 1 construction and a major pump station. Those are cost drivers, and anyone who drives Boston Post Road would notice the work.
The state has already backed the planning work. Connecticut DEEP's FY2026 Clean Water Fund Intended Use Plan lists a $2,239,098 planning reserve for "wastewater treatment and subsurface dispersal system at Old Saybrook High School." That money is a planning reserve. It is not a construction budget.
The May 2026 presentation gives an "Opinion of Cost" of $33,500 to $51,300 for Alternative 1 and $51,800 to $79,300 for Alternative 2. Under the Alternative 1 figure, the slide lists inflation, number of zones, cost per EDU and life-cycle costs as the variables. These are an engineer's opinion-of-cost ranges, not a bill the town has issued.
Phases I and II are built and being assessed. The phase for the five remaining areas is still moving through environmental review and a public process.
As of November 2026, the process looks like this:
After that, the consultant's scope includes posting a CEPA scoping notice in the state's Environmental Monitor, running a public hearing on that notice, completing the Environmental Impact Evaluation for both alternatives, and preparing a record of decision. The final schedule will be set by the WPCA and DEEP.
The town's septic rule reaches past the district lines. Old Saybrook's on-site ordinance runs a townwide program that requires "pump-out, inspection and maintenance" at least once every five years.
The WPCA tracks compliance in what it calls the "Carmody" database and mails reminder postcards twice a year.
How do I know which focus area a property is in? The district boundary is defined by an overview map and 15 district maps dated May 28, 2009, kept on file with the Town Clerk. The town's ordinance chapter explains how those maps work.
Has a property already been upgraded? About 1,100 properties in the district had been upgraded as of Fuss & O'Neill's September 2026 project summary. The WPCA and the Tax Collector, which processes Phase I and II assessments, can confirm the status of a specific parcel.
Where can I follow the Phase III vote? The WPCA agenda center posts agendas and minutes for its monthly meetings.
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm how any ordinance or assessment applies to a specific property with the town and with your attorney or financial advisor.
If you're weighing a cottage in Plum Bank, Indiantown, Chalker Beach or anywhere else in the district, Teri Lewis can help you line up the focus-area map and the WPCA calendar. Request a Concierge Consultation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Teri is extremely personable and will work tirelessly for your needs. Her attention to detail and her honest and personable approach is what she longs for each in every transaction. She will not only find you a home, but will also help you find the right fit for your family and also give you a concierge approach when transitioning into the area she so loves.